Kotsko's Index of Forbidden Words -- Part 5
by Adam Kotsko
It's been a while since I've excluded any words from our
discourse, but I've noticed that people have been getting
progressively stupider since my last installment. This is more a
public service than anything.
- Pretensious -- This is used primarly by Amazon reviewers
to criticize anything that highly educated people enjoy: French
philosophers, obscure novelists, Radiohead, etc. The implication is
that the highly educated people don't know what they're talking about
and are just pretending to like certain things in order to appear
intelligent. The reviewer, on the other hand, knows the real truth
and is showing up all these "pseudo-intellectuals" (consider this word
a sub-entry on the list) for the morons they are. The weird thing,
though, is that the people who critique those who are pretensious
never seem to offer anything positive. It might even be that they are
just trying to appear smart by not going to the trouble to
understand anything that's difficult to understand: "Those people
think they're smart, but I'm so smart that I know that the stuff they
like is stupid before I even engage with it at all." So who's
pretensious now?
- "Get it" -- I hear this constantly, especially in math
classes. Do they want everything to be as easy as putting popcorn in
the microwave? Yes, graphing trigonometric functions is hard at
first. Yes, even multiplication is hard at first. When something is
hard, that's not an automatic sign that it's stupid and worthless or
that you're stupid and worthless. It just means you're going to have
to take some time, maybe read something, maybe just let it percolate
in the back of your brain for a while. So shut up and stop
complaining about how you don't "get it." Nothing your teacher can
say this second will make it suddenly "click" (let's stop using
"click" in that sense, too).
- Fair -- When people say something isn't "fair," they're
really saying, "I'm not getting what I want." If you don't like a
situation, that's fine: say so. Take responsibility for what you want
without trying to rally a universal principle to your side.
- "Writ large" -- This is somewhat obscure, and I apologize
for this. Generally, it's used by magazine writers who are trying to
be clever: "The 2000 election controversy was like a playground
dispute writ large" or whatever other asinine thing. The term "writ
large" comes from a poem by John Milton entitled "On the new forces of
Conscience under the Long Parliament," which ends with the line,
"New Presbyter is but Old Priest writ Large." He's
referring to the Presbyterian revolution in England, which was
supposed to allow freedom of expression as opposed to the Anglican
(priestly) Church. Milton is saying that the presbyters aren't
interested in freedom of thought at all; they just want to enforce a
different orthodoxy from what the Anglicans enforced. In other words,
"presbyter" is just a long, complicated way of saying essentially what
"priest" says. It does not mean that the problem with presbyters is
the same as the problem with priests, only on a larger scale -- Milton
was well aware that there were more people under the rule of priests
than under the relatively new system of presbyters. It's not hard to
come up with valid uses of the expression: "The supposed 'economic
stimulus package' is just a 'tax cut for the rich' writ large" or "The
'preemptive strike against Iraq' is just a 'war for the benefit of oil
companies' writ large" or whatever. But since no one has ever gotten
it right in the history of the world since Milton wrote the poem, I
think we'd be better off laying this one to rest.
- Issues -- When you say you have "issues," you mean that bad
things have happened to you in the past that still affect you. You
know what a clearer way to say it might be? "I am alive." Just shut
up. Seriously. Why does everyone have to be an amateur psychologist?
- God's will -- This one should be pretty self-explanatory.
|